Common Order:
1. The above writ petitions are filed with a similar cause of action wherein the respondent Nos.2 and 3 allegedly refused to register and release the sale deed in favour of the writ petitioners with respect to land in certain survey numbers of Chinthapalli Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District in the absence of notification under Section U/s. 22 A (2) of the Registration Act and the same is assailed seeking direction to the respondent Nos.2 and 3 to register and release the sale deed in favour of the writ petitioners. In that context the following are the prayers sought in the above writ petitions respectively.
2. The W.P.No.22727 of 2015 is filed with the following prayer:
“ …. to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the orders passed in appeal No.1 of 2015, dt.29.05.2015 & refusal order No.10 of 2013 of Book-2, dt.28.03.2013 passed by respondent Nos.2 & 3 respectively in refusing to register and release the sale deed executed in favour of the petitioner for the land is Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 & 585 to an extent of Ac.4.05 Gts. of Chinthapally Village and Mandal of Nalgonda District in the absence of notification U/s. 22 A (2) of the Registration Act, 1908 is as arbitrary, illegal and against the facts on record and principles of natural justice apart from voilative of Articles 14 & 300-A of Constitution of India and set aside the same and consequently, direct the respondent Nos.2 & 3 to entertain the document for registration and release the same in favor of the petitioner forthwith and …….”
3. The W.P.No.22760 of 2015 is filed with the following prayer:
“ …. to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the orders passed in appeal No.2 of 2015, dt.29.05.2015 and refusal order No.11 of 2013 of Book-2, dt.28.03.2013 passed by respondent Nos.2 & 3 respectively in refusing to register and release the sale deed executed in favour of the petitioner for the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 & 585 to an extent of Ac.4.05 Gts. of Chinthapally Village and Mandal of Nalgonda District in the absence of notification U/s. 22 A (2) of the Registration Act, 1908 is as arbitrary, illegal and against the facts on record and principles of natural justice apart from voilative of Articles 14 & 300-A of Constitution of India and set aside the same and consequently, direct the respondent Nos.2 & 3 to entertain the document for registration and release the same in favor of the petitioner forthwith and …….”
4. The W.P.No.22791 of 2015 is filed with the following prayer:
“ …. to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the orders passed in appeal No.4 of 2015, dt.29.05.2015 and refusal order No.13 of 2013 of Book-2, dt.28.03.2013 passed by respondent Nos.2 & 3 respectively in refusing to register and release the sale deed executed in favour of the petitioner for the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 & 585 to an extent of Ac.2.24 Gts. of Chinthapally Village and Mandal of Nalgonda District in the absence of notification U/s. 22 A (2) of the Registration Act, 1908 is as arbitrary, illegal and against the facts on record and principles of natural justice apart from voilative of Articles 14 & 300-A of Constitution of India and set aside the same and consequently, direct the respondent Nos.2 & 3 to entertain the document for registration and release the same in favor of the petitioner forthwith and …….”
5. The W.P.No.22827 of 2015 is filed with the following prayer:
“ …. to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the orders passed in appeal No.3 of 2015, dt.29.05.2015 and refusal order No.12 of 2013 of Book-2, dt.28.03.2013 passed by respondent Nos.2 & 3 respectively in refusing to register and release the sale deed executed in favour of the petitioner for the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 & 585 to an extent of Ac.5.17 Gts. of Chinthapally Village and Mandal of Nalgonda District in the absence of notification U/s. 22 A (2) of the Registration Act, 1908 is as arbitrary, illegal and against the facts on record and principles of natural justice apart from voilative of Articles 14 & 300-A of Constitution of India and set aside the same and consequently, direct the respondent Nos.2 & 3 to entertain the document for registration and release the same in favor of the petitioner forthwith and …….”
6. Heard Sri P. Sasidhar Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioners and Sri Bhukya Manglilal Naik, learned Government Pleader for Endowments for the respondent Nos.4 and 5. Perused the entire record.
7. The pleadings in all the writ petitions are similar except for the difference in the extent of land that is the subject matter of each of the writ petition. Therefore, the pleadings of the parties which are common are commonly discussed as follows:
8. As per Sethwar 1345 Fasli, the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 totaling an extent of Ac.18.32 Gts., is recorded as Kairathi-Inam lands held by Seshagiri Buchi Ramaiah. Said lands are non-service inam lands abolished vide Act No.VIII of 1955 under the Rules framed as the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Abolition of Inams Rules, 1975. According to Section 4 of the Act, the erstwhile Inamdars who were in possession of the Inam lands as on the date of vesting i.e. 01.11.1973 are entitled to Occupancy Right Certificate. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Miryalaguda in whose jurisdiction the subject lands are situated issued Occupancy Right Certificate in favour of Adithyuni Vishwanatham for the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 vide File No.N1/457/76 and his name is mutated in the revenue records. Said orders have attained finality. The entire land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 588 and 585 for the total extent of Ac.18.32 Gts. was mutated in the name of Adithyuni Shesha Sharma under a succession and he became the absolute owner and possessor of the land and was issued with Pattadar Pass Book and Title Deed No.821 U/r 26 of A.P Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books Act, 1971. Said Adithyuni Shesha Sharma and his family members consisting of Adithyuni Sathyanarayana, Kiran @ Suryanarayana, Bhanu Prakash, Swetha and Murali executed Agreement of sale-cum-GPA vide registered Document No.3667 of 2006 dated 11.05.2006 in favour of Sammidi Vijaya Ram Reddy for the total extent of Ac.18.32 Gts. apart from other land in Sy.Nos.582, 583 and 584 to an extent of Ac.8.23 Gts. making the total extent of land Ac.27.15 Gts. At this juncture, the respondent No.5 i.e. the Assistant Commissioner of Endowments, Nalgonda District, requested the respondent No.2, the District Registrar, Nalgonda, vide Letter No.C/6/2006 dated 01.06.2006 not to entertain registered sale deeds on the subject lands by laying claim to said lands as belonging to Gattupathi Venkateswara Swamy's Temple. The purchaser Sammidi Vijay Ram Reddy sold the lands to an extent of Ac.27.15 Gts. in favour of Sammidi Ranjith Reddy. Said document was presented before the respondent No.3, the Sub-Registrar for registration. The respondent No.3 issued a Notice No.301 of 2006 dated 05.12.2006 stating that the subject lands are claimed to be endowment land and therefore, directed Sammidi Ranjith Reddy to obtain a No-objection certificate to process the registration of sale deed. In view of said notice, the owner of land Sammidi Vijaya Ram Reddy filed Writ Petition No.19718 of 2007 before this Court to declare the Letter No.C/6/2006 dated 01.06.2006 and consequential Notice No. 301/2006 dated 05.12.2006 as illegal and void with a prayer to register the sale deed under pending document No.P/282 of 2006. While said writ petition was pending, Sammidi Vijaya Ram Reddy filed an application before RDO, Nalgonda for issuance of No Objection Certificate. After enquiry, the RDO, Nalgonda issued No Objection Certificate vide Reference No.F/115/2009 dated 28.07.2009 with an observation that subject land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 of Chinthapalli Village are patta lands and therefore, there is no objection for registration. Consequently, the respondent No.3 registered the sale deed as Document No.6708 of 2009 in favour of Sammidi Ranjith Reddy. Immediately thereafter, Sammidi Vijaya Ram Reddy has withdrawn the writ petition. The patta was mutated in the name of Sammidi Ranjith Reddy in the revenue records and he was issued with pattadar pass book and title deed No.V- 949496 vide Patta No.1634 for an extent of Ac.27.15 Gts. Said Ranjith Reddy sold said land to the petitioners as follows:
i) In Sy.No.582 Extent Ac.1.00 Gts., Sy.No.583 Extent Ac.0.20 Gts., Sy.No.584 Extent Ac.0.26 Gts., Sy.No.585 Ac.1.00 Gts., Sy.No.556 Extent Ac.0.23 Gts., Sy.No.557 Extent Ac.0.16 Gts., and Sy.No.558 Extent Ac.0.25 Gts., totaling Ac.4.30 Gts. to the Writ Petitioner in W.P.No.22727 of 2015 vide sale deed dated 3225 of 2013 dated 08.03.2013. Said document was partly registered for the land in Sy.Nos.582, 583 and 584 to an extent of Ac.2.06 Gts. The remaining extent of land falling in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 to an extent of Ac.2.24 Gts. was refused to registration by respondent No.3 on the ground that said property is under the Prohibitory List in the office of the respondent No.6 vide Lr.No.B/86/2011 and that the respondent No.4 vide Lr.Rc.No.NN1/34576/2007 dated 13.10.2008 kept the document pending registration as P.No.109/2013.
ii) In Sy.No.582 Extent Ac.3.10 Gts., Sy.No.583 Extent Ac.0.38 Gts., Sy.No.584 Extent Ac.0.25 Gts., Sy.No.585 Ac.2.00 Gts., Sy.No.556 Extent Ac.0.21 Gts., Sy.No.557 Extent Ac.0.12 Gts., and Sy.No.558 Extent Ac.0.12 Gts., totaling Ac.8.38 Gts. to the Writ Petitioner in W.P.No.22760 of 2015 vide sale deed dated 3226 of 2013 dated 08.03.2013. Said document was partly registered for the land in Sy.Nos.582, 583 and 584 to an extent of Ac.4.33 Gts. The remaining extent of land falling in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 to an extent of Ac.4.05 Gts. was refused to registration by respondent No.3 on the ground that said property is under the Prohibitory List in the office of the respondent No.6 vide Lr.No.B/86/2011 and that the respondent No.4 vide Lr.Rc.No.NN1/34576/2007 dated 13.10.2008 kept the document pending registration as P.No.110/2013.
iii) In Sy.No.582 Extent Ac.1.00 Gts., Sy.No.583 Extent Ac.0.20 Gts., Sy.No.584 Extent Ac.0.26 Gts., Sy.No.585 Ac.1.00 Gts., Sy.No.556 Extent Ac.0.23 Gts., Sy.No.557 Extent Ac.0.16 Gts., and Sy.No.558 Extent Ac.0.25 Gts., totaling Ac.4.30 Gts. to the Writ Petitioner in W.P.No.22791 of 2015 vide sale deed dated 3228 of 2013 dated 08.03.2013. Said document was partly registered for the land in Sy.Nos.582, 583 and 584 to an extent of Ac.2.06 Gts. The remaining extent of land falling in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 to an extent of Ac.2.24 Gts. was refused to registration by respondent No.3 on the ground that said property is under the Prohibitory List in the office of the respondent No.6 vide Lr.No.B/86/2011 and that the respondent No.4 vide Lr.Rc.No.NN1/34576/2007 dated 13.10.2008 kept the document pending registration as P.No.112/2013.
iv) In Sy.No.582 Extent Ac.2.00 Gts., Sy.No.583 Extent Ac.0.30 Gts., Sy.No.584 Extent Ac.0.30 Gts., Sy.No.585 Ac.2.11 Gts., Sy.No.556 Extent Ac.0.25 Gts., Sy.No.557 Extent Ac.0.20 Gts., and Sy.No.558 Extent Ac.2.01 Gts., totaling Ac.8.37 Gts. to the Writ Petitioner in W.P.No.22827 of 2015 vide sale deed dated 3227 of 2013 dated 08.03.2013. Said document was partly registered for the land in Sy.Nos.582, 583 and 584 to an extent of Ac.3.20 Gts. The remaining extent of land falling in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 to an extent of Ac.5.17 Gts. was refused to registration by respondent No.3 on the ground that said property is under the Prohibitory List in the office of the respondent No.6 vide Lr.No.B/86/2011 and that the respondent No.4 vide Lr.Rc.No.NN1/34576/2007 dated 13.10.2008 kept the document pending registration as P.No.111/2013.
9. Aggrieved by refusal order dated 28.03.2013 of respondent No.3, appeals are preferred by the petitioners before respondent No.2 vide Appeal Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4 of 2015 under Section 72 of Registration Act along with all the supporting documents such as Sethwar, ORC issued by RDO, Miryalaguda, No Objection Certificate issued by RDO, Nalgonda in proof of ownership. However, the respondent No.2 did not consider the documents and held that the evidence produced does not prove that the subject lands are private patta lands. In that context, the petitioner pleads that the Sethwar prepared under Telangana Land Revenue Act, 1317 Fasli shows that the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 are non-service inam lands categorised as Kairathi, that an ORC was issued in the year 1976 and therefore, said land is purely private patta land. The ORC has never been challenged. The classification in Sethwar is the basis and all the subsequent records are in accordance with the Sethwar. The Agreement of salecum- GPA Document No.3667 of 2006 dated 11.05.2006, the registered sale deed Document No.6708 of 2009 were registered but surprisingly when it came to the case of the writ petitioner, registration was refused and therefore, the writ petitioner was constrained to invoke Article 226 of Constitution of India.
10. The respondent No.3 filed counter stating that the Commissioner, Endowments Department, Hyderabad, vide letter Rc.No.NNI/34576/2007 dated 13.10.2008 informed that immovable properties relating to Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions, Endowment Institutions under Section 22-A(1)(c) of Registration (A.P.Amendment) Act, 2007 are prohibited from registration as the said lands are required for maintenance of Charitable and Religious Institutions. Said properties are prohibited from registration without specific permission from the Commissioner, Endowments Department. In said list, the land in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 of Chinthapally Village and Mandal, belonged to Shri Gattupathi Venkateshwara Swamy Temple. The Tahsildar, Chinthapally, through letter dated 12.01.2011, sent a list of prohibitory properties showing the subject land being included in the list as prohibited from registration. It is pleaded that the State Legislature has brought an enactment through A.P.Act 19 of 2007 by inserting Section 22-A of Registration Act. Said section prohibited registration of immovable property owned by Religious and Charitable Endowments or Wakfs other than those empowered by the statute. Further, it is stated that the writ petitioner presented document with respect to subject land and the document was kept pending by the respondent No.3. The refusal order passed by the respondent No.3 was challenged by the petitioners by way of appeals before the respondent No.2 in Appeal Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4 of 2015. The respondent No.2 issued notice dated 01.05.2013 requesting to furnish evidence in possession of writ petitioners to prove that the subject land is not endowment land. The petitioner has issued reply dated 29.04.2013 stating that he is the absolute owner of the subject property. Then the respondent No.2 addressed letters dated 01.11.2013 and 14.10.2014 to the Commissioner, Endowments seeking clarification whether the lands in Sy.Nos.585, 556, 557, 558 of Chinthapally Village are endowment lands or not. The Commissioner responded vide Letter Rc.No.D/3181/2013 dated 28.02.2015 clarifying that total extent of Ac.18.32 Gts., in Sy.Nos.585, 556, 557 and 585 of Chinthapally Village are notified as Endowment land and therefore, prohibited from registration under Section 22(A)(1)(c) of Registration Act. After examining the evidence filed and perusing the records in the office of respondent No.3 and the correspondence from the Endowments Department, the respondent No.2 rejected the appeal vide order dated 29.05.2015. Against said order, the writ petitioner has alternative remedy of filing a suit under Section 77 of the Registration Act. Without exhausting said remedy, the writ petition is filed. It is pleaded that the writ petition is misconceived and is liable to be dismissed.
11. The respondent Nos.4 and 5 filed counter denying the case of the writ petitioner and making a counter claim that the land in the subject survey numbers is meant for the benefit of a religious institution and therefore, the respondent No.3 has rightly refused registration. According to the respondent Nos.4 and 5, Sri Gattupathi Venkateshwara Swamy Temple, Chinthapally Village and Mandal is an ancient temple endowed with vast landed property. Said land was granted by the erstwhile Nizam's Government for the purpose of meeting Nitya Dhoopa Deepa Naivedyam to the deity and celebration of festivals. The subject land of the writ petition is part and parcel of the Nizam's grant. The basic record for endowment is the old revenue records and the District Collector used to administer the institutions as Collector, Endowments and pass necessary budgets. The record and budget estimates submitted by the Archakas show that considerable extent of land measuring 181 acres is meant for the benefit of the temple and the land in the subject survey numbers are included. On account of misrepresentation by the occupiers, ORC was issued by the revenue authorities in respect of certain lands including the subject lands. The record clearly shows that Inams are held for the benefit of Charitable and Religious Institutions and no person is entitled to be registered as an occupant. Any such occupancy certificate shall be deemed null and void and no effect shall be given to such registration. Even the persons belonging to Archaka family are not entitled to get absolute rights as pattadars over disputed land. The sale agreements or documents executed by the Archakas in favour of others are invalid. Due to misuse and mismanagement of endowed properties by the Archaka family members in two phases, by conducting panchanamas on 25.06.1991 and 25.03.2003, possession of the endowed property was taken over by the revenue authorities and handed over to Endowment Authorities. The subject land is also included in said survey and handed over to the Endowment Department. The respondent No.5 requested the respondent No.2 not to register any sale deeds with respect to land in the subject survey numbers and therefore, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 have rightly rejected the registration. It is further pleaded that lands belonging to Religious and Charitable Institutions in the absence of declaration by the Endowment Tribunal, that said land is not endowed, no authority is entitled to issue NOC. Therefore, NOC issued by the RDO, Nalgonda has no validity. The respondent Nos.4 and 5 pleaded that the land which is vested for the benefit of religious institution, no authority is entitled to modify the nature of the land, causing loss to the institution. Further, it is emphasized that there is no evidence produced to show that the subject lands are private pattadar lands. The petitioner did not approach Endowment Tribunal stating that the lands are not endowed and has moved the High Court misrepresenting facts. In view of the circumstances stated, the ORC and NOC as well as Pattadar Passports issued by Revenue Authorities are invalid and therefore, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 have rightly refused registration with respect to lands in Sy.Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585. It is pleaded that four writ petitions are filed in that regard and all the four writ petitions are liable to be dismissed.
12. The Writ Petitioners filed a reply to the counter filed by the respondent Nos.2 and 3 denying the subject lands requirement for maintenance of Charitable and Religious Institutions. Further, the writ petitioner denied communication of letter dated 12.01.2011 furnishing the List of Prohibitory Properties by the Tahsildar, which includes the subject land. The prohibitory properties are not notified under Section 22-A(2) of Registration Act. Mere communication between the respondent Nos.4 to 6 claiming the subject land belonging to Religious Institutions cannot be countenanced unless there is a notification issued under Section 22-A(2) of Registration Act. Further, it is pleaded that the writ petitioner furnished documents to establish right, title and physical possession over the subject land before the Appellate Authority, but the Appeal Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4 of 2015 have been rejected holding that no documentary evidence is produced in proof of title and possession. Further, it is pleaded that availability of an alternative remedy is not a bar to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. While reiterating the writ petitioners’ case for registration, it is pleaded that the impugned refusal order dated 28.03.2013 by respondent No.3 and the order dated 29.05.2015 in Appeal by the respondent No.2 are passed on erroneous appreciation of facts by placing reliance on the communication addressed by the respondent Nos.4 to 6. Further, it is pleaded that prohibition as to registration of a document relating to Endowment property can operate only with notification issued under Section 22-A(2) of Registration Act and it is not open to respondent Nos.4 and 5 to communicate letter to respondent Nos.2 and 3 to refuse registration. Lastly, it is pleaded that the respondent No.6 under Section 5 and sub proviso 1 to 7 is empowered to register the subject land and issue pass books by making necessary entries in the revenue records. As such, prayed that the writ petitions be allowed.
13. The petitioners filed a reply to the counter filed by the respondent Nos.4 and 5 alleging that the subject land is not endowed with Sri Gattupathi Venkateshwara Swamy Temple, Chinthapally Village granted by erstwhile Nizam’s Government to meet the expenditure towards Nithya Dhoopa Deepa Naivedyam and for celebration of festivals. Obtaining Occupancy Rights Certificate through misrepresentation is denied. The registering of an occupant where Inam lands are held by Religious Institutions under Inam Abolition Act is of no relevance for the case set out by the petitioner. The pleading about the members of Archaka family using the income over the lands or alienating the land is denied. Further, conduct of panchanama on 25.06.1991 and 25.03.2003 is also denied. Lastly, it is denied that the subject lands belong to a Religious Institution. In the absence of declaration by the Endowment Tribunal, no authority is entitled to issue an NOC based on a registered document and said NOC having no validity is denied. The writ petitioner failing to produce documents in proof of subject land being private patta land is denied. The ground for registration is denied. The case of subject lands being Kairathi Inam lands held by Seshagiri Buchi Ramaiah and passed on through registered sale deeds is reiterated, alleging that there is failure to appreciate the fact that subject lands are private patta lands. It is pleaded that no documents are placed along with the counter affidavit to substantiate the claim that the subject land is endowed land and therefore, the pleadings of the counter affidavit are based on surmises and conjectures. It is pleaded that Section 22-A(i)(c) of Registration Act presupposes title of religious institution and merely prohibits registration of document executed by those without authority. Prohibition as to registration of a document relating to Endowment property can operate only with a notification issued under Section 22-A(2). In the absence of such notification, the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 do not have any ground to refuse registration on the basis of Letter Rc.No.D/3181/2013 dated 28.02.2015. Such communication is without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained. It is again reiterated that as per Section 2(13) of Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Book Act, the respondent No.6 and under Section 5 and sub proviso 1 to 7, the respondent No.6 is empowered to register the subject land and make necessary changes in the revenue records and therefore, it is prayed that direction be given to respondent No.6 to receive, register and release the sale deed.
Contentions of the writ petitioners:
14. The learned counsel for writ petitioners submits that the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 have refused to register the sale deed for lands covered under Survey Nos.556, 557, 558 and 585 in Chinthapally Village, despite the fact that there was no notification under Section 22-A of the Registration Act, 1908. According to the learned counsel for writ petitioners, the mere communication of Letter Rc.No.D/3181/2013 dated 28.02.2015 is not sufficient to refuse registration. In that context, the learned counsel for writ petitioners referred to judgment of this Court in the case of Lingala Padma v. The State of Telangana (2025 SCC OnLine 2697), wherein it is held that unless the lands covered under Clause 22-A (1)(e) are notified in a Gazette, the document presented for registration shall be registered. Further, in the absence of a Gazette notification, listing the properties of the Endowment Department under prohibited list, the District Registrars cannot refuse to register a document. It is further held that as per Rule 242 of Chapter XXXIII of Rules 2016 under the Registration Act, a registering officer shall refuse to register any document pertaining to lands mentioned in the prohibited list prepared under Rules 238 to 241. Further, as per Rule 243, the competent officer can cancel the registered document provided the properties registered are mentioned in the prohibited list under Section 22-A. Since the subject lands in Lingala Padma (supra) were not notified in a Gazette, a Coordinate Bench of this Court allowed the writ petitions by setting aside the impugned orders therein, with a direction to set aside the unilateral cancellation of registered sale deeds executed in favour of the writ petitioners therein. The same legal ratio was followed by another Coordinate Bench of this Court, in the case of Sankiti Tirupati Reddy v. State of Telangana (W.P.No.1053 of 2026 and batch, dated 09.01.2026, TSHC.).
15. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners further relied upon the case of Pasuparthi Jayaram v. Government of Andhra Pradesh (2013 SCC Online AP 694), wherein it is held that in the absence of a notification under Section 22-A (2), it is not open to the Endowments Department to communicate a list of properties allegedly only owned by the religious institutions by way of a letter and trace the power to do so to Section 22-A (1) (c) of the Registration Act, 1908. In the case of Syed Zakir Hussain v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2013 SCC OnLine AP 613), it is held that only a list of persons who are statutorily empowered to execute the documents could be communicated to the registration authorities under the provision and not a list of properties belonging under Section 22-A(2) of the Registration Act. Further, it is held that if the Government is in a position to assert and establish its title over the subject land, then it is open to the Government to approach proper forum in accordance with law and seek appropriate relief. In the case of T. Prem Singh v. State of Telangana (2021 SCC OnLine TS 2855), by placing reliance on Syed Zakir Hussain (supra), it is held that in the absence of notification under Section 22-A(2) of the Registration Act, there is no legal basis for refusal of registration by the concerned authorities to receive and register the documents presented by the writ petitioner.
16. Further, in the case of M/s. Invecta Technologies Private Limited v. Government of Andhra Pradesh (2023 SCC OnLine 4565), there are guidelines issued by the State Government for exercise of power under Section 22-A of the Registration Act, wherein the District Collectors have to furnish lists of properties prohibited under the statutes to the Registering Officers. Any deletions or modifications to the list should be sent to the Commissioner and Inspector General of Registration and Stamps, who in turn will furnish the same to the concerned registering officers having jurisdiction over such property. In said guidelines, it is also directed that prohibited properties under Section 22-A are to be published with such details on website duly updating the information from time to time. It is concluded that the entire procedure of preparing lists of properties covered under Clauses (a) to (e) and as to forwarding of such list and notifying said list is mandatory.
17. Further, in the case of Vinjamuri Rajagopala Chary v. Revenue Department (2015 SCC OnLine Hyd 407), it is held that no notification contemplated under subsection (2) of Section 22-A is necessary with respect to properties falling under Clauses (a) to (d) of subsection (1) of Section 22-A, whereas the properties covered under clause (e) of Section 22-A (1) shall be notified in official Gazette of the State Government and shall be forwarded along with list of properties. It is argued that the judgment in Vinjamuri Rajagopala Chary (supra) is no longer a good law. The same was challenged before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the Hon'ble Supreme Court has remanded the matter for fresh consideration by this Court and said process has not concluded till date.
18. In the case of Siri Nivasam Mutual Aided House Building Society Limited v. State of Andhra Pradesh ((2018) 16 SCC 786), there is an observation by a Coordinate Bench of this Court about similar matters being remitted to a Bench concerned concerning the issues relating to validity of Section 22-A of the Act. The main issue pending before the High Court being the vires of Section 22-A of the Act, since the issue is pending, all the appeals on registration were permitted subject to result of the appeals.
19. In the case of BHEL Employees Model Mutually Aided Cooperative House Building Society Limited v. State of Telangana (2021 SCC OnLine TS 3640), it is held that the judgment in Vinjamuri Rajagopala Chary (supra) has been set aside and remitted to this Court for fresh consideration about vires of Section 22-A of the Registration Act.
20. On the basis of aforementioned citations, it is argued that the judgment in the case of Vinjamuri Rajagopala Chary (supra) has been set aside and the matter is remanded back to this Court for considering the vires of Section 22-A of the Registration Act. While said issue is pending consideration, the judgment in the case of Lingala Padma (supra) and other judgments come to the aid of writ petitioners for registration and release of the sale deed. It is argued that the act of the respondents-Registration Authorities is arbitrary and therefore, prayed that the writ petitioners be granted the relief sought for.
Contentions of the respondent Nos.4 and 5:
21. The learned Government Pleader for Endowments opposed the writ petitions, alleging that the writ petitioners have an alternative remedy available under Section 77 of the Telangana Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act, 1987, to challenge the orders passed in the appeals by the concerned Appellate Authority which confirmed the refusal orders of registration. In that context, the learned GP for Endowments, relied upon the case between Srikakulam Jute Mills Private Limited v. The State of Andhra Pradesh (W.A.No.815 of 2022, dated 04.05.2023, APHC.), wherein there is an issue about inclusion of subject property in the list of prohibited properties notified under Section 22-A (1) (c) of the Registration Act, 1908. There was a letter issued communicating the prohibited list without following due procedure. In that context, the Division Bench of High Court of Andhra Pradesh declined to entertain a writ appeal as title issues cannot be decided by invoking the power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
22. Further, reference is made to a judgment rendered by a Division Bench of High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati in the case of M/s. Sri Santhi Nikethan v. State of Andhra Pradesh (W.A.Nos.888 and 899 of 2022, dated 23.09.2023, APHC.), wherein it is held that the Tribunal constituted under the Endowment Act has jurisdiction to determine whether any property is an endowment or a charitable endowment or a religious endowment. Since an alternative remedy is available, the Writ Court refused the relief which the petitioners are seeking.
23. Further, reference is made to a judgment passed by a Division Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal No.1404 of 2024, dated 17.06.2025, wherein it is held that when the Endowments Tribunal has power to decide the disputes relating to Telangana Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act, 1987, this Court need not entertain the petition as there is an efficacious alternative remedy available.
24. In the case of Smt. T. Kalpana v. The Joint Sub-Registrar-I, Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh (W.A.No.500 of 2012, dated 09.10.2012, APHC.), a Division Bench of High Court of Composite State of Andhra Pradesh held that if the purchase of land is owned by an endowment institution, then automatically Section 22-A of the Registration Act will apply and the only forum to approach would be the Endowments Tribunal.
25. The respondents also referred to the judgment of this Court in Invecta Technologies (supra), wherein it is held that no notification contemplated under subsection 2 of Section 22-A is necessary with respect to properties falling under Clauses (a) to (d) of subsection 1 of Section 22-A. With respect to properties covered under Clauses (c) and (d), the authorities have to forward the lists, the extracts of registered Gazette if the property is covered either by endowment or waqf. On the basis of aforementioned judgment it is argued that the writ petitions are not maintainable as an efficacious remedy is available before the Endowments Tribunal.
26. In that context, the judgment in the case of Lingala Padma and others (supra) is to the effect that under Clauses (a) to (d), the title of properties belonging to either the State Government or the Central Government or an endowment institution or properties declared to be surplus under Land Ceiling Act are covered. In the instances of properties falling under Clauses (a) to (d) of Section 22-A of Registration Act, there is no dispute with respect to title as the title has already been crystallised. Whereas there is a necessity for listing of properties which fall under Section 22-A (1) (e) as there is an interest of either the State Government or an endowment or a waqf which has not yet crystallised. Since the rights are not yet crystallised, the concerned authorities have to prepare a list of such properties commonly referred as prohibited properties and communicate to the District Registrar, who in turn would communicate the list to the Sub Registrars of concerned jurisdiction.
Analysis of the Court:
27. In the backdrop of rival contentions, when the present case is considered, it is seen that the writ petitioners are claiming the subject property to be private patta land. In support of said claim, the writ petitioners have produced copy of registered sale deed No.6708 of 2009, dated 18.11.2006, copy of registered AGPA with possession No.3667 of 2006, dated 11.05.2006, ORC issued by RDO dated 13.09.2007, No Objection Certificate No.F/115/2009, dated 28.07.2009, copy of Sethwar of the year 1345 Fasli, copy of Sesala Pahani of the year 1955-58, Certificate No. B/5056/2006 issued by M. R.O., Chinthapally Mandal, Letter No.B/24/90, dated 20.11.1996 and copy of pattadar pass books and title deed along with copy of English translations in W.P.No.22727 of 2015.
28. On the basis of aforementioned documents, it is contended that the subject land is patta land and therefore does not fall under the category of lands as in Section 22-A(1)(c) of Registration Act. It is argued that once the subject lands are patta lands, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 have no authority to refuse to register the said land and release the sale deed. It is emphasized that in case subject land is a land belonging to any endowment, then the respondent Nos. 4 to 6 are under obligation to list the same under prohibited list and issue a Gazette and then communicate the same to the concerned Sub-registrar. In the absence of such a procedure, more particularly in the absence of an official Gazette, it is argued that the case in Lingala Padma (supra) makes it clear that the concerned Sub-registrar has no authority to refuse registration.
29. Coming to the case of respondents, it is seen that the respondents have submitted a memo with material papers consisting of Khasra Pahani, Pahani Patrikas proceedings and patta certificate with translations. A perusal of said documents shows that the subject lands are in the name of Vishwanatham Buchiramaiah but not Gattupati Venkateshwara Swamy Temple. A perusal of each and every document including Khasra Pahani and the Pahanies for the subsequent years shows the entry of name of A. Buchiramaiah as the person who is in occupation of the subject land. The proceedings issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Endowments Department however shows that land in Survey Nos.558 and 585 belongs to Sri Gattupati Venkateshwara Swamy Devasthanam of Chinthapally Village and Mandal. The survey numbers covered are 556, 557, 559 and 585, except the proceedings issued by the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments Department, the rest of the record shows the name of A. Vishwanatham. Strangely, there is an occupancy patta certificate issued in No.RE/649/97 dated 03.04.1999 in the name of Gattupati Venkateshwara Swamy, Chinthapally Village and Mandal and said list does not contain the Survey Nos.556, 557, 559 and 585. In the year 2006, the Office of Assistant Commissioner, Endowments Department, referred Rc.No.C/411/2006, dated 10.02.2006 to the District Collector stating that land in Survey Nos. 558 and 585 to an extent of Ac.4-23 guntas and Ac.2-13 guntas respectively in addition to other survey numbers belongs to the Gattupathi Venkateshwara Swamy Temple. Thus, the record provided by the respondent authorities themselves shows that the pahanies show name of A. Vishwanatham and Buchiramaiah, whereas the proceedings issued by the Endowments Department show the name of Sri Gattupati Venkateshwara Swamy Temple. The documentary evidence produced by the respondents leaves an ambiguous situation of setting up rival title on behalf of Shri Gattupathi Venkateshwara Swamy Temple to the title setup by the writ petitioners.
30. In view of rival claims made by the respondents and the writ petitioners, the subject lands falls under the category of Section 22-A (1) of Registration Act, which requires publication of a Gazette notification consisting of list of properties prohibited from registration. In the absence of such notification as per the judgment of this Court in Lingala padam and Pasuparthi Jayaram (both supra) and others makes it clear that the respondent Nos.2 and 3 do not have any authority to refuse registration and release of a sale deed merely on the basis of internal communication from the respondent Nos.5 and 6.
31. The citations relied upon by the respondents can be distinguished as they do not deal with the issue of issuance of a Gazette notification of prohibited properties. The judgments cited by the respondents are limited in scope about there being a title dispute over subject land between private parties and Endowment Department and therefore, a remedy is available before the Endowment Tribunal. In fact in case the Endowment Department has any claim over the subject lands of the writ petitioners, the respondents are also entitled to approach the Endowment Tribunal to establish their title over subject land.
32. In the instant case, this Court is concerned only with the validity of inaction of the respondent Nos.2 and 3 in registering the subject land in the absence of publication of a Gazette notification of properties which are prohibited from registration. In that context, the legal ratio laid down in Lingala Padma and Pasuparthi Jayaram (supra) are squarely applicable, wherein there is a categorical finding about the registering authorities being under obligation to register the subject property when said property is not notified by way of Gazette. In the circumstances, the inaction rather refusal of the respondent Nos.2 and 3 to register the subject property in favour of the writ petitioners is not sustainable.
33. In the result, the writ petitions are allowed setting aside the orders dated 29.05.2015 in appeal Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4 of 2015 and refusal orders dated 28.03.2013 in refusal order Nos.10, 11, 12 and 13 of 2013 of Book-2 passed by respondent Nos.2 and 3. Consequently, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 are directed to register the sale deeds executed in favour of the petitioners, if otherwise in order, as per the law. There shall be no order as to costs. Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending shall stand closed.




